|
What is St.
John's wort?
St. John's wort (Hypericum perforatum in Latin) is a long-living plant
with yellow flowers. It contains many chemical compounds. Some are believed to
be the active ingredients that produce the herb's effects, including the
compounds hypericin and hyperforin.
How these compounds actually work in the body is not yet known, but several
theories have been suggested. Preliminary studies suggest that St. John's wort
might work by preventing nerve cells in the brain from reabsorbing the chemical
messenger serotonin, or by reducing levels of a protein involved in the body's
immune system functioning.
For what
medicinal purposes has St. John's wort been used?
St. John's wort has been used for centuries to treat mental disorders as well as
nerve pain. In ancient times, doctors and herbalists (specialists in herbs)
wrote about its use as a sedative and treatment for malaria as well as a balm
for wounds, burns, and insect bites. Today, St. John's wort is used by some
people to treat mild to moderate depression, anxiety, or sleep disorders. In
Europe and especially Germany, St. John's Wort is prescribed twice as often as
standard antidepressants for depression. Other historical uses include:
-
Nervous
conditions, including anxiety, depression, and traditionally for many other
psychiatric ailments
-
Wound management
-
Kidney
conditions
-
Sleep disorders
-
Inflammation
-
Bacterial
infection
What is
depression?
Information on depression is available from the National Institute of Mental
Health. Here is a brief overview.
Depression is a medical condition that affects nearly 19 million Americans each
year. A person's mood, thoughts, physical health, and behavior all may be
affected. Symptoms commonly include:
-
Ongoing sad mood
-
Loss of interest
or pleasure in activities that the person once enjoyed
-
Significant
change in appetite or weight
-
Oversleeping or
difficulty sleeping
-
Agitation or
unusual slowness
-
Loss of energy
-
Feelings of
worthlessness or guilt
-
Difficulty
"thinking," such as concentrating or making decisions
-
Recurrent
thoughts of death or suicide.
Depressive illness
comes in different forms. The three major forms are described below. Each can
vary from person to person in terms of symptoms experienced and the severity of
depression.
-
In major
depression, people experience a sad mood or loss of interest or pleasure
in activities for at least 2 weeks. In addition, they have at least four
other symptoms of depression. Major depression can be mild, moderate, or
severe. If it is not treated, it can last for 6 months or more.
-
In dysthymia,
a milder, but more chronic form of depression, people experience a depressed
mood for at least 2 years (1 year for children) accompanied by at least two
other symptoms of depression.
-
In bipolar
disorder, also called manic depression, a person has periods of
depressive symptoms that alternate with periods of mania. Symptoms of mania
include an abnormally high level of excitement and energy, racing thoughts,
and behavior that is impulsive and inappropriate.
Some people still
hold outdated beliefs about depression--for example, that the emotional symptoms
caused by depression are "not real." However, depression is a real
medical condition. It can be treated effectively with medicine, including
St.John's wort.
Why is St. John's
wort used as an alternative therapy for depression?
Some patients who take antidepressant drugs do not experience relief from their
depression. Other patients have reported unpleasant side effects from their
prescription medication, such as a dry mouth, nausea, headache, or effects on
sexual function or sleep.
Sometimes people turn to herbal preparations like St. John's wort because they
believe "natural" products are better for them than prescription
medications, or that natural products are always safe.
Finally, cost can be a reason. St. John's wort costs less than many
antidepressant medications, and it is sold without a prescription (over the
counter).
How widely is St.
John's wort used for treating depression?
In Europe, St. John's wort is widely prescribed for depression. In the United
States, St. John's wort is not a prescription medication, but there is
considerable public interest in it. St. John's wort remains among the
top-selling herbal products in the United States.
Depression
Depression can be
a serious illness with many potentially serious consequences, and its
treatment should always be prescribed and supervised by a qualified physician.
The following is for informational purposes only, and should not be construed
as, nor is it a substitute for, professional medical advice.
Depression Is a
Common Manifestation of Stress
If you're
depressed, you are not alone. Depression afflicts nearly 17% of all Americans
in the U.S. for the length of their lives. Furthermore, depression is nothing
to be embarrassed of or shy about; quite to the contrary: those afflicted tend
to be more gifted and higher achieving than their non-depressed peers. Indeed,
stress (i.e., the stress commonly associated with achieving people) is a
consistent cofactor in depressed people. It is in relieving this stress that
St. John's Wort and nearly every prescribed pharmaceutical anti-depressant
achieves its anti-depressant qualities. It is important to note that stress is
the same no matter how it manifests itself; it is because of this that
anxiolytic drugs and herbs are able to relieve so many disorders - ranging
from depression to gastric upset to use as weight control agents.
A Note On
Environmental and Genetic Causes
Depressed
patients' environmental stresses play a major role in their disease. Most of
these influences are better addressed with a licensed psychologist, however a
few obvious factors bear note. Low light levels, poor sleep habits, and poor
diet can, in combination or singly, provide the necessary factors for inducing
depression. A good first line of treatment that you don't need a prescription
for is as follows: increased exposure to bright light (the brighter the
better), good sleep habits (depressed people's sleep schedules tend to rotate
clockwise; staying up later and sleeping in longer - don't fall into this
pattern! You should also be sleeping in a dark room and waking up under bright
lights), and a balanced
diet - by "balanced" is meant 40-30-30; the 40-30-30
method balances good and bad prostaglandins, chemicals normally produced by
the body, but which are highly influenced by the foods we eat and which have
significant bearing on one's state of well-being.
It is suspected
that depressed people's increased sensitivity to stress may also carry a
hereditary component. Whether this is the case or not, is beyond the scope of
this discussion, and not relevant to treatment anyway; one certainly hopes
that investigation into genetic inheritance would yield results for future
generations. For the remainder, we will concern ourselves with what to do if
you are depressed and leave how it happened to the researchers.
Three Types Of
Anti-Depressant Agents
-
Tricyclics
-
monoamine
Oxidase Inhibitors (MAOI's)
-
Selective
serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRI's - we will also include the MSRI's,
or Mixed serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors in this category, since it was
through the same mode of inquiry as the SSRI's that they were developed)
A little on brain
chemistry will help to understand the action of these drugs. The human brain
is teeming with chemicals, in fact, if you look closely enough, it's all
chemicals! Without getting into philosophical discussions, suffice it to say
that it would appear to some that all thoughts and all emotions have their
chemical counterparts that can be studied under the microscope. If you're not
comfortable with this sort of reductionistic view of the psyche, relax, there
is plenty we don't know and plenty of room for alternative or supplemental
models of understanding. It is only that the method of inquiry currently being
pursued by medical science is that of "isolate and tweak", which, so
far has had its rewards.
Two of the major chemical players in the brain when it comes to depression,
are neurotransmitters known as serotonin and norepinephrine. These
neurotransmitters, like all neurotransmitters, work something like the way
keys fit into locks. On the one side there's the neurotransmitter, or the key,
and on the other the lock, known as the receptor site. Every neurotransmitter
has a specific receptor site that only it, or chemicals with similar
structures "fit" into. When a neurotransmitter is received at its'
receptor site, information is transmitted, whether it's a feeling of well
being (serotonin, norepinephrine, et. al.), euphoria (opiates, for example),
pain (acetaldehyde - i.e., the chemical metabolite of alcohol that yields the
infamous "hangover"), a rush of excitement (epinephrine, also known
as adrenaline), or some other chemical information. Once a chemical is
received it is eaten up by another chemical called an enzyme. Monoamine
oxidase is one of these enzymes. Think of enzymes as performing a janitorial
chore in your brain.
One by one, let's look at how these agents work:
Trycyclics are wide ranging in their action on the brain's neurotransmitters
and for this reason are termed "dirty". This is not "dirty' as
in "bad" or containing dirt, but unselective in the brain chemicals
that they affect. They affect the re-uptake of both serotonin and
norepinephrine, allowing these two chemicals to hang around longer and do
their thing before they are eaten up by the enzymes. Tricyclics also affect
other brain chemicals, but for simplicities' sake, we will only address
serotonin and norepinephrine.
MAOI's, as their name implies, work on the "lock" side of the
reaction, by blocking the action of the monoamine oxidase, the enzyme that
eats serotonin and norepinephrine. By blocking their reuptake, serotonin and
norepinephrine are left to work their action for longer periods of time (MAOI's
vary in their ability to block MAO, there is usually enough left to eventually
degrade the neurotransmitters, it only takes longer). The problem with MAOI's
is that they leave the brain open to the action of other chemicals (other
amines) as well, not just serotonin and norepinephrine. This means that a
person taking an MAOI has to avoid certain sources of otherwise harmless
chemicals. These sources unfortunately include chocolate, aged cheeses, red
wines, fava beans and many other commonly enjoyed foods. The repercussions of
an accidental ingestion of these foods (actually, the tyramines they contain)
while under the influences of an MAOI is staggering, and can range from
hypertensive or hypotensive crisis to stroke and, possibly, death.
SSRI's, also as their name implies, affect only the reuptake of serotonin, and
are thus considered "clean" in their action. They have proven quite
effective in treating depression.
Undesired Side
Effects
The main complaint
with modern anti-depressant therapy is that of undesired side effects. The
tricyclics are antihistiminic, which leads to dry mouth, hypostatic blood
pressure (dizziness on standing from a relaxed position), constipation,
urinary retention, carbohydrate cravings, excessive drowsiness, blurred vision
and others. In short, the tricyclics are hard to tolerate, owing to these side
effects. The MAOI's - well, if you can consider stroke a "side
effect"... These aren't used often anymore. The best, the
"clean", or specific drugs, the SSRI's, have a whole host of their
own side effects as well: agitation, insomnia, loss of libido, and impotence
are among them.
IF YOU ARE ALREADY ON ONE OF THESE DRUGS...
You should know that these side effects are not always present, and will
almost always subside upon stopping the drug. Do not, under any circumstance
stop your medication abruptly, or without contacting your attending physician!
Do not under any circumstance mix drugs - and St. John's Wort is a drug.
Hypericin,
Hyperforin and How St. John's Wort Works
Most studies on
St. John's Wort were done on leaf standardized to 0.3% hypericin. This always
was ONLY a marker compound - a reference or bench mark - to help control the
studies and used by various pharmacopoeias in establishing guidelines. In
other words, nothing antidepressant about hypericin itself has ever been
established, although there is mounting evidence that hyperforin is a 5-HT
serotonin reuptake inhibitor. Hyperforin is the second compound to have been
identified from this plant and suspected as having antidepressant effects.
Hyperforin is naturally present in St. John's Wort leaf in the amount of about
4% - no special process is needed to get this. This is why we have ALWAYS sold
St. John's Wort standardized to 0.3% hypericin and supplemented with whole
leaf (this insures nothing is left out, since we really don't KNOW what it is
that makes this plant work). Initially it was thought that St. John's Wort's
antidepressant effects were due to MAO inhibition - probably an incorrect
hypothesis since the MAO inhibiting activity of St. John's Wort is minimal at
best. We are left with the question, HOW does it work? Some interesting
hypothesis have been proposed; here are two of them:
The Immune System
Modulation Hypothesis
Cytokines are
mediators involved in cell-to-cell communications. Interleukins are types of
cytokines involved in hemopoesis (regeneration of red blood cells) and immune
response. One of these is a protein called interleukin-6 (IL-6) (there are 12
known interleukins). IL-6 is also involved in cellular functions in the
nervous system. Specifically, IL-6 activates the
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, resulting in increased production of
Corticotropin-releasing hormone (or "CRH") - the hypothalamic
peptide which stimulates corticotropin release from the pituitary gland.
Increased production of corticotropin means release of adrenaline, which means
STRESS! St. John's Wort has been demonstrated through in vitro experiments to
greatly reduce the release of IL-6. This hypothesis has not been tested in
vivo, but it is compelling because it provides a hypothetical link between St.
John's Wort's known immune system and antidepressant effects.16
The SSRI
Hypothesis
Simply put, there
is a great deal of evidence accumulating that hyperforin selectively blocks
the reuptake of serotonin.3,4,9,14,17 If this is found to be true,
what we will have is a naturally occurring SSRI - like Prozac! Studies have
shown that hyperforin alone produces results comparable to that of whole St.
John's Wort leaf.3 Another study compared St. John's Wort with
differing hyperforin content and identical hypericin content.9 That
with the greater hyperforin content came out on top.
What We Know
In the end, like
the now obsolete MAOI hypothesis, neither of the above hypotheses may prove
true - maybe both will; fortunately this has little impact on practical
application. We know that it does work, and we know what methods of
standardization produce the desired results. While we wait for the answer, any
product that is standardized to 0.3% hypericin AND contains whole leaf should
have a hyperforin content of about 4% and will work.
St. John's Wort
Is Cost Effective
Users of St John's
Wort enjoy the same or better level of relief from depression when compared to
traditional pharmaceutical agents, but without the annoying side effects! They
also save money. St John's Wort is comparatively cheap: one month's supply of
Effexor at 75mg/day costs approximately $150, one month's supply of St. John's
Wort, at an effective level, costs approximately $15. St. John's Wort offers a
low risk and credible benefit at a low price.
The Safety of St.
John's Wort
The safety of St.
John's Wort as listed by the Botanical Safety Handbook12, an
industry guide published by the AHPA, and conservative in its recommendations
notes that it "may potentiate pharmaceutical MAO-inhibitors". The
German Commission E Monographs2 notes that "photosensitization
is possible, especially in fair-skinned individuals"; no
contraindications are listed, nor are restrictions during pregnancy or
lactation listed. The Herbal PDR7 notes that "no health
hazards are known in conjunction with the proper administration of therapeutic
dosages. The tannin content of the drug can lead to digestive complaints, such
as feeling of fullness or constipation. Photosensitization has been observed
in animals following intake of large quantities of the drug (starting at 3 g
per kg of body weight, which would be 150 g for a person weighing 50 kg) (hypericismus).
However, such a reaction is unlikely with administration of therapeutic
dosages." The Textbook of Natural Medicine16 notes that
"there have been no deaths due to St. John's Wort toxicity, a stark
contrast to the 31 deaths per 1 million prescriptions produced by synthetic
prescriptions." Most importantly, if you decide to take St. John's Wort,
please discuss it with a qualified physician, you will be surprised at how
receptive many physicians are to this remarkable herb.
Drug Interactions
The medical
journal, The Lancet, has published a study that showed that a drug interaction
has been found with St. John's Wort.5 The interaction is that of an
inhibitory effect on a protease inhibitor called indinavir, which is used in
the treatment of HIV. The Lancet also published, in the same issue, a study
that showed that St. John's Wort may also stimulate the rejection of
transplanted hearts.5 From this new information, scientists
postulate that it is likely that St. John's Wort works along a metabolic
pathway (particularly one involving the liver). THEREFORE, it may render such
drugs as birth control less effective. If you are currently taking a drug that
works along a metabolic pathway (your doctor will know), St. John's Wort may
not be for you. Consult a physician.
|